Thursday, December 22, 2011

My Review of Le Fanu's "Why Us?"

Here's my review of the atrociously bad book, Why Us?, by James Le Fanu. It appeared in Reports of the National Center for Science Education, 31 (6) (2011).

7 comments:

D. Swart said...

More examples of bipedal animals:

Birds of all kinds especially the flightless ones; Theropods like the T.Rex.

The Atheist Missionary said...

Great review - thank-you for posting. Will tweet.

Bayesian Bouffant, FCD said...

"The thesis of Why us? is simple: science has no answers to the questions that really matter - questions like: ... How does an immaterial mind affect the material body? ..."

I guess he has a point. Science has no answer to that one, other than to say that he's asking the wrong question.

cody said...

I really liked the second example, with the reference to Hubbard. Examples 3, 4 (no other species dares try balance on two legs, why even I myself sometimes struggle to master it!), and 6 (succinct!).

I also love the spin of "I don't get it" as "impenetrable obscurity".

And I didn't know you testified in the Dover case, that's pretty neat.

Jeffrey Shallit said...

I didn't testify - I was asked to testify. I was deposed, but since Dembski dropped out on the opposing side, my testimony in court was not needed.

cody said...

I'd like to think my inference was mistaken!
...But I suspect I should read more carefully.
I wonder if there is a difference.

Garkbit said...

You must have been sorely tempted to cut that review down to just its last two words. That would have been _so_ cool.